Black Phone 2 Reviews Unveiled: A Thrilling Dive into Ethan Hawke’s Latest Horror Hit

Black Phone 2 Reviews are starting to pour in, offering a thrilling look at Ethan Hawke’s return as the sinister Grabber in this highly anticipated sequel.

Released just hours ago on September 22, 2025, the film has already garnered attention following its premiere at the Fantastic Fest in Austin, Texas.

Directed by Scott Derrickson, this follow-up to the 2021 hit promises a darker, more expansive tale, and early reactions are stirring excitement among horror fans.

What Do Critics Say About the Plot?

The story picks up years after Finney’s escape, with Mason Thames reprising his role as a now 17-year-old haunted by his past.

According to Roger Ebert’s review published September 22, 2025, the plot shifts to Gwen, played by Madeleine McGraw, who receives chilling calls from the black phone, leading to visions of missing boys at a winter camp.

This setup has been praised for its eerie atmosphere, with Variety noting the film’s bold move into supernatural territory beyond the original’s grounded horror.

Facts confirm the setting moves to 1982, as detailed on IMDb, with a runtime of 1 hour 54 minutes rated R. Speculation about a Freddy Krueger-inspired twist, however, stems from fan forums and lacks official backing, though the climax on ice has drawn comparisons to classic slasher finales.

How Does Ethan Hawke’s Performance Shine?

Ethan Hawke’s portrayal of the Grabber continues to impress, with Rotten Tomatoes aggregating a 78% approval rating based on 50 reviews as of September 22, 2025.

Critics highlight his ability to blend menace with vulnerability, especially in a scene where the Grabber taunts from beyond the grave, as noted by The Hollywood Reporter.

His return was teased in the trailer, and early feedback suggests he elevates the film’s tension.

Rumors of Hawke improvising key lines circulate online, but no verified source confirms this. His four-time Oscar-nominated status, per Wikipedia, adds weight to the performance, making it a focal point of the sequel’s success.

What Are the Standout Visuals and Direction?

Scott Derrickson’s direction receives high marks for its unsettling visuals, particularly Gwen’s nightmare sequences.

Roger Ebert praises a shot of a face split by glass as “true nightmare fuel,” while the ice climax is lauded for its creativity, reminiscent of 1980s horror classics.

Production used practical effects alongside CGI, as confirmed by a behind-the-scenes feature on the film’s official site updated September 21, 2025.

Fan theories about hidden Easter eggs, like nods to The Exorcist, remain unverified. The film’s budget, estimated at $20 million per Box Office Mojo, reflects a commitment to quality over flash, enhancing its gritty appeal.

Are There Any Criticisms to Note?

Not all feedback is glowing. Some reviews, like one from The Wrap on September 22, 2025, suggest the plot feels overstretched compared to the original, with side characters underdeveloped.

The shift to a larger ensemble has sparked debate, though the core performances keep it afloat. These critiques are based on verified reviews, while claims of reshoots derailing the vision are unconfirmed rumors from social media.

The film’s ambition to blend genres is a double-edged sword, but its 78% score indicates a strong reception overall, per Rotten Tomatoes data.

What’s the Verdict on Black Phone 2 Reviews?

Black Phone 2 Reviews paint a picture of a sequel that builds on its predecessor with bold choices and standout performances.

Ethan Hawke’s chilling return, paired with Derrickson’s visionary direction, makes it a must-watch for horror enthusiasts.

As more reviews trickle in ahead of the October 17, 2025, release, the film’s legacy in the genre looks promising.

Grab some popcorn and brace yourself for a frightful ride!