Peacemaker: Season 2's Rotten Tomatoes Reviews Signal a Triumphant DCU Return

Peacemaker: Season 2's Rotten Tomatoes Reviews have sparked widespread excitement, debuting with a perfect 100% Tomatometer score based on 34 critic reviews.

This stellar reception for the John Cena-led series, set to premiere on August 21, 2025, on Max, positions it as a standout in superhero television. The reviews highlight a darker, more heartfelt continuation of the DC Universe (DCU) narrative, building on the success of its first season and James Gunn’s vision for the rebooted franchise.

Below, we break down what critics are saying and explore what this means for the eagerly awaited show.

Key Takeaways:

• Perfect Score: Season 2 debuted with a 100% Rotten Tomatoes score, Certified Fresh based on 34 reviews.

• Critical Acclaim: Critics praise the season as "darker," "more heartfelt," and "better than the first."

• John Cena’s Performance: Described as the best work of Cena’s career, balancing humor and emotional depth.

• DCU Integration: Fully canon in the new DCU, with ties to Superman and Creature Commandos.

• Premiere Date: Premieres August 21, 2025, with weekly episodes on Max.

What Makes Season 2 a Critical Hit?

Critics have lauded Season 2 for elevating the elements that made the first season a success. The show, created and directed by James Gunn, retains its signature blend of irreverent humor, gory action, and emotional depth but pushes these further.

Reviews highlight a more character-driven narrative, with John Cena’s portrayal of Christopher Smith/Peacemaker earning praise for its vulnerability and complexity. The season’s Certified Fresh status reflects unanimous positive feedback, with critics noting its ability to balance absurd comedy with poignant themes like trauma and redemption.

The show’s improved Tomatometer score of 100% compared to Season 1’s 93% underscores its growth. Critics from outlets like The Mary Sue and Nerdist call it a step up, with some declaring it surpasses Gunn’s Superman in emotional resonance.

The focus on character development, particularly for Peacemaker and Emilia Harcourt, adds a grounded feel despite the introduction of multiversal elements.

How Does It Fit Into the New DCU?

Unlike Season 1, which was part of the DCEU, Season 2 is fully canon in the rebooted DCU, aligning with projects like Superman and Creature Commandos.

James Gunn has confirmed its pivotal role in setting up the broader DCU narrative, with guest stars and references to other DCU projects. The inclusion of Rick Flag Sr., played by Frank Grillo, introduces a revenge-driven antagonist tied to The Suicide Squad, adding layers to the story.

Critics appreciate how Gunn weaves these connections without losing the show’s core focus on its misfit team, the 11th Street Kids.

The season’s multiversal plot, where Peacemaker explores an alternate world, has been singled out for its emotional weight.

Reviewers note that Gunn finds resonance in the multiverse concept, a feat Marvel has struggled to achieve. This narrative choice not only expands the DCU but also deepens Peacemaker’s personal journey, making it a compelling entry point for new viewers.

What’s New in the Cast and Story?

Returning cast members include John Cena as Peacemaker, Jennifer Holland as Emilia Harcourt, Freddie Stroma as Vigilante, Steve Agee as John Economos, Nhut Le as Judomaster, and Robert Patrick as Auggie Smith/White Dragon.

New additions like Frank Grillo, David Denman, Sol Rodriguez, Michael Rooker, and Tim Meadows bring fresh dynamics. Critics highlight the ensemble’s chemistry, with the supporting cast shouldering more comedic weight, allowing Cena to explore darker, more serious facets of his character.

The story picks up after the events of Season 1, with Team Peacemaker reeling from Amanda Waller’s actions. A new opening title sequence featuring Foxy Shazam’s “Oh Lord” replaces the iconic “Do Ya Wanna Taste It?” dance number, promising a fresh yet equally memorable vibe.

Reviews praise the inventive fight choreography, gnarly action scenes, and Gunn’s impeccable music choices, which continue to set the show apart.

Are There Any Criticisms?

While the reviews are overwhelmingly positive, some critics note minor flaws. A few, like AwardsWatch, suggest the season feels like an exercise in universe expansion at times, with characters potentially better suited to other DCU projects.

Others mention that the humor, while still abundant, doesn’t always land as consistently as in Season 1. However, these critiques are outliers, as most reviews emphasize the show’s ability to deliver a cohesive, entertaining experience.

The smaller sample size of 34 reviews compared to Superman’s 500 suggests the score may shift as more critiques roll in post-premiere. Still, the current consensus positions Season 2 as a must-watch, with its mix of heart, madness, and action resonating strongly.

Why Is the Show a Standout in Superhero TV?

Peacemaker Season 2 distinguishes itself in the crowded superhero genre through its unique tone. Critics describe it as “darker and sadder” yet “hilarious” and “heartwarming,” striking a balance that feels fresh.

The show’s R-rated humor, brutal action, and focus on flawed characters make it a standout, with comparisons to Deadpool and Daredevil for its irreverence and depth. Gunn’s ability to humanize obscure characters, as seen in his Guardians of the Galaxy work, shines through, making Peacemaker a fan favorite.

The series also benefits from its weekly release schedule, starting August 21, 2025, with eight episodes culminating on October 9. This format, combined with Gunn’s tight control over spoilers (he withheld the final three episodes from critics), builds anticipation and ensures a fresh viewing experience.

Some Closing Thoughts: A Promising Chapter for DC Fans

Peacemaker Season 2’s Rotten Tomatoes reviews paint a picture of a bold, emotionally rich continuation that cements James Gunn’s vision for the DCU.

With a perfect score, standout performances, and seamless integration into the new DCU, the show promises to deliver for both longtime fans and newcomers.

As it prepares to drop on Max, the critical acclaim suggests it’s not just a sequel but a defining moment for superhero television.

Tune in on August 21 to see why critics are calling it a bloody, hilarious, and heartfelt triumph.