Superman’s First Reviews: David Corenswet’s Clark Kent/Superman Steals the Show?

Superman’s First Reviews are lighting up the internet, and David Corenswet’s portrayal of Clark Kent/Superman in James Gunn’s Superman 2025 is earning major buzz.

Premiering at the TCL Chinese Theatre on July 7, 2025, and hitting theaters worldwide on July 11, this DC Universe DCU reboot marks Corenswet’s debut as the iconic hero, following in the footsteps of legends like Christopher Reeve.

With a star-studded cast including Rachel Brosnahan as Lois Lane and Nicholas Hoult as Lex Luthor, the film has sparked debate, but Corenswet’s performance is a consistent highlight.

From heartfelt praise to mild critiques, let’s compile every critic and fan comment on how Corenswet embodies the Man of Steel in this bold new chapter for DC.

What Are Critics Saying About Corenswet’s Superman?

A Sincere and Heroic Superman

Critics are raving about Corenswet’s ability to capture Superman’s essence. Bryan Sudfield of the Life Moves Pretty Fast Podcast praised his sincerity and strength, calling him a bold yet faithful take on the iconic hero.

Brandon Davis of the Phase Hero podcast went further, lauding Corenswet’s sincerity, heroism, purity, and inspirational traits, noting he embodies the Superman fans crave.

Davis highlighted his off-the-charts chemistry with Brosnahan’s Lois Lane, making their dynamic a heartwarming cornerstone of the film.

These reviews position Corenswet as a beacon of hope, aligning with Gunn’s vision of a kind, optimistic hero.

Comic-Book Charm and Emotional Depth

Rachel Leishman on X described Corenswet as shining in a comic book brought to life, evoking hope and happiness, @RachelLeishman, July 8, 2025. Her enthusiasm reflects how Corenswet nails Superman’s larger-than-life presence while grounding Clark Kent’s humanity.

On the Life Moves Pretty Fast Podcast, another critic noted Corenswet sells the heart of Clark Kent, balancing awkward charm with Kryptonian confidence. This duality, blending Clark’s bumbling reporter persona with Superman’s godlike power, draws comparisons to Reeve’s iconic performance, with reviewers saying Corenswet honors that legacy while adding modern flair.

Chemistry and Charisma

Corenswet’s interactions with the cast elevate his performance. Critics like Brandon Davis emphasized his electric chemistry with Lois Lane, creating tender, believable moments.

A review from Fandango’s Erik Davis indirectly praised Corenswet by calling the film a terrific start, implying his central role anchors the narrative. Even in mixed reviews, Corenswet shines.

Nicola Austin, despite noting a convoluted plot, said Corenswet’s charisma carries key scenes, making Superman relatable and inspiring.The Critiques: Boyish but Beaten?

Not every comment is glowing. Toronto Star’s Peter Howell offered a nuanced take, calling Corenswet’s Superman boyishly sweet but constantly getting his ass kicked, suggesting he lacks the commanding presence some expect.

Howell’s critique implies Corenswet leans heavily into Clark’s vulnerability, which may not fully satisfy fans of a more dominant Superman.

On X, @filmsbyJuan gave a backhanded compliment, praising Corenswet’s effort in a cheap TV show looking movie, indicating his performance outshines a flawed film.

These critiques suggest Corenswet’s youthful, earnest approach divides opinions, particularly among those wanting a grittier hero.

Fan Reactions on X: Corenswet’s Superman Sparks Passion

A New Icon Emerges

Fans on X are largely thrilled with Corenswet. @bestever23 compared the film to Raimi’s Spider-Man, calling Corenswet bold and heartfelt, suggesting he captures Superman’s emotional core.

@neilvagg, after a 30-minute preview, praised how Corenswet embodies 30 years of comic lore, making him a perfect fit for Gunn’s vision.

These reactions highlight Corenswet’s ability to resonate with comic fans, delivering a Superman who feels both timeless and fresh.Mixed but Positive Vibes

Some fans echo critics’ critiques. @ecranlarge.bsky.social, while regretting Zack Snyder’s darker Superman, acknowledged Corenswet’s charm but felt the film’s tone undercuts his gravitas.

@htshowbiz, aligning with harsher reviews, still noted Corenswet’s likability as a saving grace. These comments show Corenswet’s performance is a standout, even for those less sold on the film, reinforcing his potential to define the DCU’s Superman.

Highlights of Corenswet’s Superman Performance:

• Sincere Heroism: Critics praise Corenswet’s heartfelt, inspirational Superman, evoking truth and justice.

• Chemistry King: His dynamic with Rachel Brosnahan’s Lois Lane is electric, anchoring the film’s emotional core.

• Comic-Book Fit: Fans and reviewers say Corenswet nails Clark Kent’s charm and Superman’s power, honoring comic roots.

• Youthful Critique: Some call his Superman boyishly sweet, lacking dominance, dividing traditionalist fans.

• Release Date: Superman, starring Corenswet, hits theaters July 11, 2025, after its July 7 premiere.

Why Corenswet’s Performance Matters

A New Superman for a New DCU

Corenswet’s casting was a bold choice, stepping into a role immortalized by Reeve and redefined by Henry Cavill. At 32, Corenswet brings a youthful energy, aligning with Gunn’s vision of a Superman grappling with his Kryptonian heritage and human upbringing, per The Sunday Times.

His performance, drawing from All-Star Superman’s optimistic hero, aims to reset DC’s cinematic tone after the DCEU’s divisive run, like Batman v Superman’s 28% Rotten Tomatoes score.

Critics and fans agree Corenswet’s sincerity and charm make him a strong foundation for the DCU’s Chapter One: Gods and Monsters.

Bridging Comic Fans and Newcomers

Corenswet’s ability to embody both Clark’s awkwardness and Superman’s heroism resonates with comic fans, as seen in @neilvagg’s praise for his lore-accurate portrayal.

Yet, his relatable, modern take, per Leishman, appeals to casual audiences, crucial for DC’s revival. His chemistry with Brosnahan and Hoult, noted across reviews, grounds the film’s fantastical elements, like kaiju battles and Krypto’s antics, making Superman a unifying figure in a packed ensemble.

Challenges and Expectations

The critiques, like Howell’s, highlight challenges. Some fans, especially Snyder loyalists on X, prefer Cavill’s stoic Superman, with @ecranlarge.bsky.social expressing nostalgia.

Corenswet’s boyish vulnerability, while endearing, may not fully meet expectations for a commanding Man of Steel, especially in a $250 million blockbuster needing broad appeal.

As the review embargo lifts on July 8, 2025, at 3 PM EST, and Rotten Tomatoes scores emerge, Corenswet’s reception will clarify his staying power.

Some Closing Thoughts:

David Corenswet’s portrayal of Clark Kent/Superman in Superman’s first reviews emerges as a highlight of James Gunn’s bold reboot.

Critics and fans praise his sincere, comic-book-inspired performance, electric chemistry, and heartfelt charm, positioning him as a worthy successor to Superman’s legacy.

While some critique his youthful, vulnerable take as too soft for the iconic hero, Corenswet’s ability to shine in a divisive film underscores his potential to anchor the DCU.

As Superman flies into theaters on July 11, 2025, Corenswet’s Man of Steel is poised to inspire hope, but will he win over all hearts? See it and decide.