The Fantastic Four: First Steps’ Rotten Tomatoes Score Soars: A Marvel Triumph?

The Fantastic Four: First Steps’ Rotten Tomatoes score has ignited excitement among Marvel fans, debuting at a stellar 88% Certified Fresh rating, a historic high for the franchise.

As Marvel Studios kicks off Phase Six with this retro-futuristic reboot, the score reflects strong critical praise for its cast, visuals, and nostalgic charm. But can this film finally deliver the cinematic justice Marvel’s First Family deserves? Let’s dive into the reviews, analyze what’s working, and speculate on what this score means for the MCU’s future.

Why Is the Rotten Tomatoes Score So High?

The Fantastic Four: First Steps has achieved an 88% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 95 reviews as of July 23, 2025, earning the coveted Certified Fresh status. This marks the first time a Fantastic Four film has received a positive consensus on the aggregator, a significant leap from the franchise’s past: 2005’s Fantastic Four (27%), 2007’s Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer (37%), and 2015’s Fant4stic (9%).

Critics are lauding the film’s vibrant 1960s-inspired setting, stellar cast chemistry, and Michael Giacchino’s iconic score. The performances of Pedro Pascal (Reed Richards), Vanessa Kirby (Sue Storm), Joseph Quinn (Johnny Storm), and Ebon Moss-Bachrach (Ben Grimm) have been highlighted as a standout, with Kirby’s Sue Storm often called the emotional core of the film.

The film’s retro-futuristic aesthetic, described as a blend of The Jetsons and Star Trek, has been praised for its accessibility and fresh take on the MCU.

Reviewers note that director Matt Shakman leans into the comic book’s kitschy roots, avoiding the gritty realism of past adaptations.

This approach, combined with a focus on family dynamics, has resonated with critics, with many calling it a return to form for Marvel after a rocky Phase Five.

What Are Critics Saying About the Performances?

The ensemble cast is a major driver of the film’s success. Vanessa Kirby’s portrayal of Sue Storm has been singled out, with critics praising her balance of strength and vulnerability, making her a dynamic leader rather than a stereotypical emotional anchor.

Pedro Pascal’s Reed Richards is celebrated for his blend of classic movie star charisma and modern sensitivity, while Joseph Quinn brings a cool, mid-century vibe to Johnny Storm. Ebon Moss-Bachrach’s Ben Grimm is noted for his humanity, despite his rocky exterior.

Julia Garner’s Silver Surfer and Ralph Ineson’s Galactus also earn praise for their compelling presence, though some reviewers find the villains underwhelming compared to the heroes.

How Does It Compare to Other MCU Films?

The Fantastic Four: First Steps’ 88% score places it in the same league as MCU heavyweights like Iron Man (94%) and Guardians of the Galaxy (92%). It matches the score of Thunderbolts*, another recent MCU hit, and surpasses James Gunn’s Superman (83%), which debuted at 89% but dropped after its second weekend.

This strong performance suggests Marvel is regaining its critical footing after mixed receptions for films like Captain America: Brave New World. The score’s stability will depend on additional reviews, but early signs point to a lasting positive impact.

What Are the Criticisms?

Not all reviews are glowing. Some critics argue the script lacks depth, with Jon Negroni of InBetweenDrafts calling it a “soulless math equation” driven by studio notes. Others, like Nick Shager of The Daily Beast, describe the film as “aggressively fine,” flirting with hokiness despite its earnest optimism.

Concerns about weak character development and inconsistent CGI have surfaced from test screenings, though these issues may be addressed before the July 25 release. These critiques suggest that while the film is a step forward, it may not fully escape the MCU’s formulaic tendencies.

Could This Score Signal an MCU Renaissance?

The Fantastic Four: First Steps’ strong Rotten Tomatoes score has sparked speculation about Marvel’s trajectory. After a challenging Phase Five, marked by critical misses and box office struggles, this film’s success could herald a new era. Its accessibility, standalone story, and setup for Avengers: Doomsday (set for 2026) position it as a pivotal moment for the MCU.

Fans and critics alike are hopeful that the film’s fresh approach and critical acclaim will translate to box office success, potentially outpacing Superman as 2025’s top superhero film. However, the score may fluctuate as more reviews pour in, and audience reactions will ultimately determine its cultural impact.

Key Takeaways:

• Rotten Tomatoes Score: The Fantastic Four: First Steps debuted at 88% Certified Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 95 reviews.

• Cast Praise: Critics laud Pedro Pascal, Vanessa Kirby, Joseph Quinn, and Ebon Moss-Bachrach for their chemistry and standout performances.

• Historic Achievement: First Fantastic Four film to earn a positive Rotten Tomatoes score, surpassing 2005 (27%), 2007 (37%), and 2015 (9%).

• Critical Reception: Praised for its retro-futuristic aesthetic, Michael Giacchino’s score, and family-driven story, though some note script and CGI issues.

• MCU Impact: Matches Thunderbolts* (88%) and outpaces Superman (83%), signaling a potential MCU critical resurgence.

Some Closing Thoughts: What’s Next for Marvel’s First Family?

The Fantastic Four: First Steps is poised to redefine Marvel’s First Family, with early reactions suggesting it’s the cinematic treatment fans have long awaited.

The film’s Certified Fresh rating and enthusiastic reviews highlight its potential to anchor Phase Six and set the stage for future MCU projects. As it hits theaters on July 25, 2025, all eyes will be on whether it can maintain its critical and commercial momentum.

For now, Marvel’s First Family is stepping confidently into the spotlight, proving that the fourth time might just be the charm.