The Paper Review: Critics and Fans React to Peacock’s Office Spinoff

Peacock’s latest sitcom, The Paper, has hit the streaming scene, sparking a wave of reactions as a quasi-spinoff of the beloved NBC series The Office. This mockumentary-style comedy, set in a struggling Ohio newspaper, has garnered praise and some critique in early reviews.

With a fresh cast led by Domhnall Gleeson and a familiar documentary crew vibe, The Paper Review(s) from across the internet highlight a show that’s both a nostalgic nod and a bold new venture. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what critics and audiences are saying about this workplace comedy.

Highlights:

• Fresh Yet Familiar: The Paper blends The Office’s mockumentary style with a new setting, earning praise for its smart writing and likable cast.

• Strong Ensemble: Domhnall Gleeson shines as editor-in-chief Ned Sampson, supported by a talented cast including Sabrina Impacciatore and Oscar Nuñez.

• Humor with Heart: The show balances sharp comedy with a tender look at local journalism, resonating with viewers.

• Room to Grow: Some note early pacing issues but commend the series’ growth by the finale.

• Season 2 Confirmed: Peacock renewed The Paper for a second season before its September 4, 2025, premiere.

What Makes The Paper Feel Like The Office?

The Paper follows the same documentary crew that filmed Dunder Mifflin, now capturing the chaos of the Toledo Truth Teller, a newspaper fighting to survive. Critics highlight its familiar mockumentary elements, like talking-head confessionals and sly workplace humor, which echo The Office’s charm.

Reviews note the show “feels like a spiritual cousin” to its predecessor while carving its own path with a focus on journalism’s struggles. The return of Oscar Nuñez as Oscar Martinez adds a nostalgic bridge, delighting fans who recognize his deadpan delivery.

How Does the Cast Elevate the Show?

Domhnall Gleeson’s portrayal of Ned Sampson, the optimistic editor-in-chief, anchors the series with earnestness and subtle humor.

Critics praise his ability to balance exasperation and hope, drawing comparisons to both Jim and Michael Scott from The Office.

The ensemble, including Sabrina Impacciatore as online editor Esmeralda and Chelsea Frei as ex-military writer Mare, brings depth to the ragtag staff.

Posts on X call the cast “first-rate” and “infectious,” with reviewers noting their chemistry as a key strength. However, some characters take time to gel, with a few critics pointing out uneven integration early on.

Why Is the Humor Both Funny and Poignant?

The Paper delivers laughs through sharp writing and workplace absurdities, like clickbait headlines and office antics, while weaving in a heartfelt ode to local journalism.

Reviews describe it as “breezy” and “good-natured,” with moments that resonate emotionally, especially for those familiar with the industry’s decline.

The show tackles real-world issues like fake news and budget cuts without losing its comedic edge. Some critics argue it leans too heavily on The Office’s formula, calling it a “carbon copy” at times, but most agree its optimism and wit make it a worthy successor.

Does the Show Find Its Footing Over Time?

Early episodes face scrutiny for pacing and establishing a unique voice, with Variety noting it “takes some time to warm up.” Yet, reviewers unanimously praise the season’s progression, with the finale showcasing the show’s potential to become a “comfort comedy.”

The 10-episode arc, released on September 4, 2025, benefits from tight editing and a growing confidence in its storytelling. Fans on X express excitement for the already-greenlit second season, hoping it builds on this foundation.

How Are Fans Reacting on Social Media?Social media buzz reflects a mix of enthusiasm and cautious optimism. Posts on X highlight the show’s humor and cast, with some users calling it “surprisingly funny” and others appreciating its fresh take on a familiar format.

While some fans initially doubted the premise, fearing it couldn’t match The Office, many now praise its charm and relevance. The announcement of a second season before the premiere fueled excitement, with users eager to see where the story goes next.

Some Closing Thoughts:

The Paper has carved a promising niche in the crowded sitcom landscape, blending nostalgia with a modern spin on workplace comedy.

Its strong cast, sharp humor, and heartfelt take on journalism make it a standout, despite minor growing pains.

With a second season already secured, the show is poised to grow into a fan favorite. Whether you’re an Office diehard or a newcomer, The Paper offers plenty to love and laugh about.

Stay tuned to this space as we bring you all the updates concerning this series.