The Smashing Machine’s First Reviews Highlight Dwayne Johnson’s Oscar-Worthy Performance

The Smashing Machine’s first reviews have ignited excitement, with critics and audiences buzzing about Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson’s transformative performance as MMA fighter Mark Kerr.

Premiering at the 82nd Venice International Film Festival on September 1, 2025, this A24 biographical sports drama, directed by Benny Safdie, has earned a stellar 93% on the Tomatometer based on 15 reviews.

Fans and reviewers alike are calling it a career-defining moment for Johnson, with early reactions pointing to potential Oscar contention. This article dives into the critical reception, key highlights, and what makes this film a must-watch, all organized in an easy-to-read table for quick insights.

Highlights of The Smashing Machine’s First Reviews:

• Tomatometer Score: 93% Fresh based on 15 reviews as of September 2, 2025.

• Standout Performance: Dwayne Johnson’s raw and vulnerable portrayal of Mark Kerr is hailed as a career-best, with Oscar buzz growing.

• Director’s Vision: Benny Safdie’s solo directorial debut delivers a gritty, emotional narrative distinct from traditional sports biopics.

• Emotional Depth: The film explores Kerr’s struggles with addiction and relationships, resonating with audiences for its authenticity.

• Festival Premiere: Debuted in competition at the Venice Film Festival, nominated for the Golden Lion.

What Makes Dwayne Johnson’s Performance a Game-Changer?

Johnson, known for blockbuster roles in films like Jumanji and Fast and Furious, steps into uncharted territory with The Smashing Machine. Critics praise his ability to shed his larger-than-life persona, embodying the complex and tormented MMA legend Mark Kerr.

The Independent’s Geoffrey Macnab noted, “This is the most raw and vulnerable that Johnson has ever been on screen.” His transformation, aided by three to four hours of daily prosthetics, including a wig and facial makeup, makes him nearly unrecognizable, adding authenticity to the role.

Johnson’s personal connection to Kerr’s story, having lost friends to addiction, further deepens his performance, making it a standout in his career.

Why Is the Film’s Narrative So Compelling?

The Smashing Machine chronicles the life of Mark Kerr, a two-time UFC Heavyweight Champion, during the no-holds-barred era of the late 1990s. The film, inspired by the 2002 HBO documentary of the same name, delves into Kerr’s triumphs in the ring and his battles with painkiller addiction and personal relationships.

Emily Blunt, playing Kerr’s then-wife Dawn Staples, complements Johnson’s performance, adding emotional weight to their tumultuous relationship. Directed by Benny Safdie, known for Uncut Gems and Good Time, the film takes a raw, arthouse approach, blending visceral fight scenes with intimate, emotional moments, setting it apart from conventional sports dramas.

How Does the Cast Elevate the Story?

The ensemble cast, including real-life fighters like Ryan Bader, Bas Rutten, and Oleksandr Usyk, brings authenticity to the MMA world depicted in the film. Emily Blunt, fresh off an Oscar nomination for Oppenheimer, delivers a powerful performance as Dawn Staples, navigating the challenges of supporting Kerr through his struggles.

Bas Rutten, a former Pancrase champion, praised Johnson’s ability to capture Kerr’s essence, noting how he mimicked Kerr’s voice and mannerisms in scenes with the Japanese press. The inclusion of actual MMA fighters like Ryan Bader as Mark Coleman adds realism, making the fight sequences feel like a time capsule of the sport’s early days.

What Are Critics Saying About the Film’s Style and Tone?

Early reactions highlight the film’s unique tone, described as a “spoof of the biopic genre” and one of A24’s “weirdest” films yet, per World of Reel. Unlike Safdie’s previous high-octane thrillers, The Smashing Machine leans into emotional depth, with scenes evoking Lost in Translation as Kerr grapples with isolation in Japan.

Critics like Variety’s Owen Gleiberman call Johnson’s portrayal a “revelation,” bridging the gap between Kerr’s intimidating octagon presence and his vulnerable personal life.

The film’s use of period-accurate cameras from PRIDE FC, as noted by MMA legend Matt Serra, enhances its immersive quality, making audiences feel like they’re at the fights.

Is The Smashing Machine an Oscar Contender?

The film’s Venice Film Festival premiere and Golden Lion nomination have sparked awards season buzz, particularly for Johnson. Solowrestling.com reports that experts see this as his chance to finally secure an Oscar nomination, a milestone he has yet to achieve.

A24’s strong track record with Oscar campaigns, as seen with Moonlight and Everything Everywhere All At Once, bolsters the film’s prospects. Critics also commend Safdie’s direction and Blunt’s supporting role, suggesting multiple categories could be in play.

With a theatrical release set for October 3, 2025, the film is well-positioned for awards consideration.

The Smashing Machine Reviews and Details Table

Will The Smashing Machine Redefine Dwayne Johnson’s Career?

With The Smashing Machine, Johnson is taking a bold step away from his action-hero archetype, embracing a role that demands emotional and physical depth. The film’s early success at Venice and its fresh Tomatometer score signal a turning point for the actor, whose career has been defined by billion-dollar blockbusters.

As he prepares for another high-profile project with Martin Scorsese and Leonardo DiCaprio, Johnson’s commitment to challenging roles is clear. Fans and critics are eager to see if this marks the beginning of a new era for the Hollywood superstar.

Some Closing Thoughts:

The Smashing Machine promises to be a gripping exploration of Mark Kerr’s life, elevated by Johnson’s career-best performance and Safdie’s visionary direction.

With its October 3, 2025, release approaching, the film is poised to captivate audiences and potentially reshape Johnson’s legacy.

Don’t miss this raw, emotional journey when it hits theaters, and keep an eye on its awards season trajectory.